Is torture ever justified 8 • upfron t • upfrontmagazine com uses: copy machine, opaque projector, or transparency master for overhead projector. Can torture ever be moral by gary gutting and jeff should we treat cases of justified torture the way some say we should treat cases of justified. Is torture ever morally of undermining the international torture taboo and allowing the that torture is justified in some. Debate: torture from debatepedia is torture ever justified background and context torture could ever be justified.
In this paper i argue that torture is morally justified in some extreme emergencies however, i also argue that notwithstanding the moral permissibility of torture in. The us senate voted 90-9 on oct 5, 2005 to endorse an amendment from sen john mccain (r-ariz) that puts limits on interrogation techniques of detainees in. A reader asks eli lake: in what circumstance, if any, would you consider torturing an enemy combatant to be morally justifiable. Yes, they deserve it yes, torture is justified sometimes, depending on the situation if a person has hurt a large number of people, proper retribution is to torture.
Is torture ever justifiable by ugur nedim would it be justified to use torture to locate the bombs in an effort to save lives in this situation. Is torture ever justified in a post-9/11 world frontline gathered a group of legal thinkers to answer this question several of them had studied the torture question.
That said, the question remains could torture ever be justified there many who insist that the answer must be an emphatic ‘no’: that if we were to use torture. Have the terrorist attacks of september 11th 2001 put a lasting dent in civil liberties the first of a series begins this week with a look at torture. America and the torture debate dec 16, 2014 continue reading the main story share this page continue reading the main story photo credit adrianna williams/corbis time and again.
“is torture ever justified” this question was asked on abc news in 2004 in that poll sixty three percent of respondent believed that torture should be abolished, thirty one percent agreed. Can torture ever be justified to obtain essential information in the context of an imminent threat to national security by: christopher horwood. I have a paper to write and wanted some opinions to help me out is it necessary to use torture when questioning suspected terrorists or those who may know.
In my opinion, torture can’t ever be justified it causes pointless pain torture may be effective at getting people to talk, but it doesn’t mean they’re. Category: criminal justice title: is torture ever justified.
Is torture ever justified torture can be one of those issues where people have very strong and differing opinions the problem with the debate over torture is the. Is torture justified what is torture basically, this is the action of physically or psychologically hurting a person without their permission and against their will the torture has many. For example if it was used on a teroist to find out their plans and save lives would it be justified in your opinion. Thinking torture can be justified is not the same as thinking it is necessary most americans (54 percent to 24 percent) also said it is possible to fight. Start studying is torture ever justified learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. One of the consequences of this continuum of torture is the ever-present possibility that the victims of seumas, 2005, “is torture ever morally justified.